Torque - Is it enough?
Question:
This patient is on tray 25 of his refinement trays. Everything is fitting well. However, the Clincheck shows correction of the Mx incisors at this point while clinically there is none. The Mx incisors still look very vertical with no improvement to OB.
I understand that the Clincheck ist just demonstrating the forces but at what point should I stop and readjust? At tray 31 the proclination stops and intrusion begins. Should I consider rescanning at that stage or can intrusion still occur with out the torque being fully expressed?

Answer:
Okay, so the question here is: the patient's in refinement trays, on tray 25. Everything's fitting well, but the ClinCheck shows more correction of the incisor torque at this point than what we're actually seeing in real life.
In real life, the maxillary incisors are very vertical. We understand that the ClinCheck is just demonstrating the forces, so at what point should we stop and do a refinement?
At tray 31, the proclination stops, and the intrusion begins. Should I consider re-scanning at that stage, or can intrusions still occur without the torque being fully expressed?
The reality is, any time you're doing a movement with a root into bone, there's a lag. As you mentioned, what’s shown here isn't exactly what’s going to happen in real life—this lag always happens. It’s going slower than expected.
Now, it’s hard to say without having the original ClinCheck, but we could over-treat this even more. I recorded something recently in response to a DeepByte question, where we discussed the need to over-treat DeepByte. If you haven’t seen full expression of the correction by the end of the aligners, you can continue with the same batch of aligners. So, don’t re-scan the patient; instead, ask the technicians to continue from the same tray you're currently on.
In this case, if the teeth are more vertical in real life and the torque hasn’t been fully corrected, you could plan to not go into the intrusion just yet. But don’t take a scan and continue from tray number 1 with the torque not expressing. On tray 25, the pressure from the trays is significant, but the movement hasn’t fully occurred yet. The tray is "spring-loaded," so to speak.
If you stop now and do a refinement with a new batch of aligners, tray 1 will be completely passive, tray 2 barely active, and tray 3 slightly more active as the movement slowly tries to occur. Right now, if the trays are fitting, these trays are at their most "spring-loaded" state and just need time to work.
So, in my opinion, you have two options:
Continue and allow the torque to express while the intrusion also begins to express.
If you want the torque to express more, take a refinement at tray 25, but instead of scanning, ask the technicians to start at tray 25 and over-treat the torque even more, since it’s already spring-loaded.
This way, you’re reinforcing the current tray's forces rather than starting over with tray 1, which wouldn’t have those same spring-loaded forces.
I hope that makes sense. If you’re trying to achieve root movement during a refinement and you need more of it, don’t get a new batch of trays based on a new scan. Always get them based on the current tray number.